I'll add one more to the thread...
E90 335i auto with I-Drive. Brake mileage showed _ _ _ _ and I had the brake light as well as red car on the lift.
- I tried re-setting multiple times and multiple ways as described in this thread. Nope
- I tried unplugging the old sensors and plugging in again. Nope
- Bought and installed new sensors. Did the reset procedure...Bingo!