Jason, as mentioned above, your expectations are a bit high considering condition of the wheels.
That finish that's coming off may indicate the wheel needs to be refinished soon, could some one with experience in OEM wheels confirm this? Kinda early for 2009..
I am looking for a clean set of 18" for a winter set myself, so if you decide to sell 189 without tires and lower the price on either set, I'd take a look at both.
I am in South Denver