I had the same dilemma as you. Black on Black and tired of the orange reflectors.
I chose the cheaper ones, the smoked ones. (found mine on craigslist)
Didn't feel like spending 70-80 bucks on reflectors. I like the look of my car with the smoked one because they still KINDA reflect and do their job... doesnt look as clean as painted ones but it's fine for me.
If I run into some wad of cash, i might switch it up with painted ones but for now I love my smokies.