So, I took it to Dave Orr's body shop. They replaced everything with OEM parts and gave the bill to Progressive. I also painted my kidneys and because they were damaged replaced them with OEM "Performance Black" kidney grills.
Went in to take a look at the car as it isn't finished yet, but looks almost ready!
Will just have to pay my deductible. Thanks everyone for their help and support.
2007 BSM e90 335i 6MT - OEM Black Lines, DiMisa Tips, JB4 G5 ISO, Black Kidneys, Cyba Scoops, ZHP Shift Knob, Mr. 5 Intake