Gladiator had the best plot of all these movies. Both Troy and Alexander are bland, at best. Cinematography was not impressive. The score failed to move me. The directing of both movies could have been better. The special effects of both movies are somewhat laudable.
Troy's script was cornier than Alexander's, although both are pretty corny. In the end, Mr. Farrel was a better actor than Brad Pitt in Troy, behind Hector. Hector was the best.