Originally Posted by J02 335i
Plug it and forget it, no big deal. You will never know the difference. We have been plugging tires at our shop for over 16 years and never seen a problem.
I understand your frustration, but in reality its a tire, plug it who cares.
I disagree, you are right a plug is no big deal but the fact of the matter is, it's a brand new tire, I could see if the OP was the one that got the screw but the tire shop should own up and replace, it's now a damaged tire any way you slice it, and it's not what the OP paid for.