If you want it done right, take it to the local indy shop. Having the flunky at a warehouse store... you sorta brought it upon yourself. Why would they be careful?
At minimum, you need to take pictures at drop off because most tire shops will tell you there is no way their machines could do that. Trust me, I have learned my lesson.
I take winter wheels or beat up stocker to Discount Tire or Walmart. I take wheels that I care about to my local indy shop (and pay and arm and a leg to ensure they don't get damaged).