My car has been rear ended thrice now. Twice the other guy had Geico. Both times horrible experience. It took four months and million phone calls to Geico before I could get my check. The only thing Geico had to reimburse me for was the rental car because I didn't get it through my Insurance. They would only give me two days of rental when the car was in the garage for 14 days.
The third experience was with Liberty Mutual, which is also my Insurance company. The experience with them couldn't have been smoother.
I literally hate Geico.