Originally Posted by E90OR
You missed the most important part of the question, which one will retain most value after 1-2 years?
You still don't get it, do you?
Do you need a weekend car? Do you need a family transporter? Do you drive it in the city? Do you drive it in the suburbs? Do you care about fuel economy? Do you care about performance?
If you only care about depreciation, then the other posters already answered your question.
I would highly suggest a used 10 speed bicycle from 1983 as your primary mode of transportation if you only care about depreciation.