34YO Male, married in Chicago suburbs. No recent tickets or accidents, last claim was a theft recovery 10 years ago. Trading up from my 2000 323i to the 2011 335d boosted my rates from $34/mo to $41/mo with full coverage, legal limits of everything, and $500 deductible, but no rental reimbursement.
Been with State Farm Mutual for around 15 years, I don't even bother price shopping anymore, because it's a waste of time. I do chuckle when I get the postcards promising to save me hundreds of dollars a year--are they going to PAY ME to take a policy?