1300 clubcard points are better than none, you got better quality tyres for a wee bit more - win win!
The F1's are the best value all year round tyres I have found. I had a set fitted to my old E39 M5 (ACS5) and found they handled nicely in the wet and dry, with good balance of comfort and road noise.
The Michelin PS2's were too expensive for what you were getting in comparison.
BTW -Tesco do the merlin passes for £46 of clubcard points so you well on your way...