Ok I ended up going with the R1 rotors and Stoptech pads. Worked with Kevin at R1 a lot and he was extremely helpful! I ended up ordering over the phone with Charlie who was also very helpful.
Also ordered some ATE type 200 to do a brake fluid flush. Excited to get this stuff on and compare to stock and previous brake setups I've used in the past.
2007 335i coupe
Jet Black on Saddle Brown | 3 Pedals