Originally Posted by mantis
dude, S5's pulls you hard backwards when you depress the clutch, it is nowhere near smooth IMO
The S5 clutch certainly takes more effort, but the feel of the shifter is butter. S5 is also has a nice interior.
That said, while I seem to be the only one, not a fan of the S5's exterior and about to order my 335i as a manual. Fun times ahead.