PayPal should cover you under the dispute? Just upload the shipping postage receipt and proof that he accepted to return for a full money back. Thats what I do in certain cases where people refuse to refund me, I win all the time. I love the paypal dispute system, so easy.
2013 E92 ///
M3 | Akrapovic GT4 | HRE C20 | KW Clubsports | Recaro Pole Position | Mode Carbon | V1 | My Daily
2013 C63 AMG | Mode Carbon | V1 | Wifes Daily