I checked Cars.com and the cheapest one that seems to have all the options is 36k. Those didn't have the color combo, and i highly doubt they were babied like your car was. I would say you should get at least 37k. But like I said, my previous offer of 25k stands
*edit* You do have a few more miles than most of the 09 cars.... I know taking care of a car like you said you did is great but some people have no clue other than looking at the odometer.*