I have the same wheels in 18 and I love them. I also had the M-6 reps on my 2008 and I think they also looked great. The same guys that are saying "played out" are the same ones that hate on everything. The reason certain wheels are popular is because they look good. If anyone wants to break the mold and try something "not played out" then by all means do it. Its not my hard earned $$$ and BMW. To the OP I think it looks great.