[adrean8j]

Ok lets fix these senseless arguments once and for all (this year at least). Did anyone actually READ the website?

First in the "Performance Engine" category the Porsche 3.8 Flat Six came 2nd. The N54 came 3rd.

In the 3litre-4litre category the e92 M3's V8 came 1st. The Porsche 3.8 Flat Six came 2nd.

In the 2.5litre-3litre category the N54 came in 1st. The Porsche 2.9 Flat Six came in 5th.

If we are going to discuss this lets put it in the proper context and category.

The Porsche Engine DID beat the BMW n54 in the Performance Category.
But in the N54's displacement category it is top-dog and Porsche could not touch it.
Now we can discuss with the facts in place....