Guys, thanks for the feedback and I totally get what your saying. However, this car, despite being only two years old, was severely abused. The headlight scratches are probably a result of two things: an idiot with some sort of sander, and an amazing amount of rock chips. The sander part you can probably imagine in your head, and the rock chip parts looks like dozens of very small bug splats. Is my only option really to either replace the headlights or keep them as is? I tried to take a picture but it just doesn't do it justice. These things look really rough