should I get these repairs from dealer

ssswu · 03-16-2015, 11:57 AM

I have a 2008 328xi. It was a little bit shaky last Saturday morning when I started the car. My wife think it's unsafe to drive so she made me to send the car to dealer to fix it and do a normal maintenance. The dealer told me it might be a misfire, but they have to do a full check to figure out.

Today, the report came out. On top of the misfire issue (charges $500+, but didn't mention it's the spark or the coil pack or something else), they also mentioned three other things to fix:
1. After resetting CBS for oil change.. oil service shows due in 25,000 miles.. this is an error in the software. Recommend performed complete vehicle software update to correct this issue
2. Found drive belt tensioner to be failing.. recommend replacing drive belt tensioner and belt
3. Found there to be engine oil leaking from the valve cover gaskets. Recommend replacing all 3 gaskets for valve cover.

I know it's not a new car, and those repairs should be taken care of. But should I get them from the dealer? It's kinda pricy... Your opinions are much appreciated!

Island Road · 03-16-2015, 12:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ssswu

I have a 2008 328xi. It was a little bit shaky last Saturday morning when I started the car. My wife think it's unsafe to drive so she made me to send the car to dealer to fix it and do a normal maintenance. The dealer told me it might be a misfire, but they have to do a full check to figure out.

Today, the report came out. On top of the misfire issue (charges $500+, but didn't mention it's the spark or the coil pack or something else), they also mentioned three other things to fix:
1. After resetting CBS for oil change.. oil service shows due in 25,000 miles.. this is an error in the software. Recommend performed complete vehicle software update to correct this issue
2. Found drive belt tensioner to be failing.. recommend replacing drive belt tensioner and belt
3. Found there to be engine oil leaking from the valve cover gaskets. Recommend replacing all 3 gaskets for valve cover.

I know it's not a new car, and those repairs should be taken care of. But should I get them from the dealer? It's kinda pricy... Your opinions are much appreciated!

There is nothing magical about the dealer techs. What needs to be done sounds fairly basic to me. If you know of a auto mechanic that you trust go there. If you want a trusted BMW shop http://www.germanperformanceservice.com/ is amazing and top quality work. Although at 105hr rate not sure how much cheaper they are then BMW but I would still rather go here then a dealer for sure.

ssswu · 03-17-2015, 09:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Island Road

There is nothing magical about the dealer techs. What needs to be done sounds fairly basic to me. If you know of a auto mechanic that you trust go there. If you want a trusted BMW shop http://www.germanperformanceservice.com/ is amazing and top quality work. Although at 105hr rate not sure how much cheaper they are then BMW but I would still rather go here then a dealer for sure.

Thank you, I will check it out.

Welterweight · 03-17-2015, 09:53 AM

Larin Automotive in Norwood is really top notch. They guys race M3's and have done some very extensive work on our cars. They can easily take care of this for you and the price is sure to be better than the dealer

AWD Addict · 03-19-2015, 11:46 AM

Boston Motor Werks in Belmont is a good non-dealer option. Now that I'm out of warranty, they do all my servicing.

Owner is a former tech from Herb Chambers. He's got all the tech the dealer has, and his pricing is fair. If you're worried they're making up work, take it to him for an honest opinion.

03-16-2015, 11:57 AM	#1
ssswu New Member 4 Rep 10 Posts Drives: 2008 E90 Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: waltham iTrader: (0)	should I get these repairs from dealer I have a 2008 328xi. It was a little bit shaky last Saturday morning when I started the car. My wife think it's unsafe to drive so she made me to send the car to dealer to fix it and do a normal maintenance. The dealer told me it might be a misfire, but they have to do a full check to figure out. Today, the report came out. On top of the misfire issue (charges $500+, but didn't mention it's the spark or the coil pack or something else), they also mentioned three other things to fix: 1. After resetting CBS for oil change.. oil service shows due in 25,000 miles.. this is an error in the software. Recommend performed complete vehicle software update to correct this issue 2. Found drive belt tensioner to be failing.. recommend replacing drive belt tensioner and belt 3. Found there to be engine oil leaking from the valve cover gaskets. Recommend replacing all 3 gaskets for valve cover. I know it's not a new car, and those repairs should be taken care of. But should I get them from the dealer? It's kinda pricy... Your opinions are much appreciated!
	Appreciate 0 Tweet Quote

03-17-2015, 09:53 AM	#4
Welterweight Major 98 Rep 1,321 Posts Drives: Truck in snow, coupe in summer Join Date: Jan 2013 Location: Boston iTrader: (3) Garage List 2012 BMW 328i [0.00] 2005 Dodge Ram Quad ... [0.00] 2009 BMW 335xi E92 [10.00]	Larin Automotive in Norwood is really top notch. They guys race M3's and have done some very extensive work on our cars. They can easily take care of this for you and the price is sure to be better than the dealer __________________ 2009 BSM E92 335xi - RR600's/FBO-VRSF/Apex Arc 8/Wedge E60 MHD/Fuel it Stage 2/BMW PE w/ Dimisa Tips/Alpina TCU/Dinan Springs/RB Inlets/3.5 Bar TMAP
	Appreciate 0 Quote

03-19-2015, 11:46 AM	#5
AWD Addict Chief Executive 300 Rep 2,886 Posts Drives: 2008 335xi 6spd Coupe Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Boston iTrader: (1) Garage List 2008 335xi [0.00]	Boston Motor Werks in Belmont is a good non-dealer option. Now that I'm out of warranty, they do all my servicing. Owner is a former tech from Herb Chambers. He's got all the tech the dealer has, and his pricing is fair. If you're worried they're making up work, take it to him for an honest opinion.
	Appreciate 0 Quote