Login






BMW Garage  BMW Meets  Register  Search  Today's Posts  Mark Forums Read 

BMW 3Series (E90 E92) Forum
>
Gas Mileage Drop with Larger/Wider Rims?


06242012, 01:05 PM  #1 
New Member
0
Rep 13
Posts 
Gas Mileage Drop with Larger/Wider Rims?
I wasn't sure what the best forum would be to ask this, but here goes...
The Car: 2009 335 xDrive Sedan 6mt with Cobb Accessport (custom dynotune). Went from stock 161 17x7.5s to Avante Garde M310 19" staggered setup. I used to average between 1920 mpg per tank both before and after my access port and dynotune (done in April 2012), depending on mix of city and highway. After I had my new rims and tired installed, i've dipped to 17mpg, which has me a bit concerned. Would larger diameter and width rims cause this drop? I'm very cognizant of my driving habits, and nothing has changed over my last two tanks of gas other than the wheels. Any thoughts? Anyone have experience with this? Thanks in advance for your help guys. 
06242012, 03:20 PM  #4 
Colonel
29
Rep 2,432
Posts 
Calculate the rolling distance of the 19's vs the 17's and see how much farther you are actually traveling per revolution. The difference will probably be the amount you are seeing. Unless you can recalibrate the Odometer, you'll always be off. The Odometer thinks you have traveled X feet per revolution and you actually traveled Y. The difference between X & Y is the change you are experiencing all other things being equal.
__________________
My speeding isn't the problem. It's the Slow Folks ahead of me that cause accidents!

Appreciate
0

06242012, 03:25 PM  #5  
New Member
0
Rep 13
Posts 
Quote:


Appreciate
0

06242012, 05:54 PM  #8  
Colonel
29
Rep 2,432
Posts 
Quote:
To get the Circumference. Multiply the tire & wheel diameter by pi ( 3.14 ). This will give you the circumference. Diameter = 20 in 20 x 3.14 = 62.8 Circumference = 62.8 inch Compare that to the Circumference of your original wheels & tires.
__________________
My speeding isn't the problem. It's the Slow Folks ahead of me that cause accidents!
Last edited by ChasVS; 06242012 at 06:01 PM. 

Appreciate
0

06242012, 08:05 PM  #9 
Captain
11
Rep 859
Posts
Drives: 2008 Montego Blue 335i
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: Atlanta/Lawrenceville

Are you doing your own math after a fill up? Or just going off what the car says? I'm sure the cars math would be off with diff spec wheels. Try it on your own next fill up

Appreciate
0

06242012, 08:57 PM  #10 
First Lieutenant
5
Rep 366
Posts 
I think the 2% is the actual loss of mileage, since there is more contact with the pavement there is more friction so there is probably a bit of real mileage loss, as well as the bit of added weight. the 10% you are seeing is probably the car doing the math based off of 17" wheels.

Appreciate
0

06252012, 08:21 AM  #13 
New Member
0
Rep 16
Posts 
It should be so.
1. You added more metal than rubber/air. So more weight and there is a formula: T= F*L, here Ttorque, Fforce came from engine(driveshaft), L length from the center of the wheen to tire surface. So the bigger diameter therefore more toque is needed. 2. If new tires ar more wideyou have more contact with pavement, therefore more grip and friction. 
Appreciate
0

06252012, 08:35 AM  #14  
Captain
6
Rep 599
Posts 
Quote:


Appreciate
0

06262012, 09:45 AM  #15 
New Member
0
Rep 23
Posts 
Watch your speed as well!

Appreciate
0

06262012, 09:52 AM  #16  
Lieutenant Colonel
44
Rep 1,545
Posts 
Quote:


Appreciate
0

06262012, 09:54 AM  #17 
Private First Class
1
Rep 106
Posts 
I recently went from 17" square to 18" staggered. Not a huge jump, but bigger wheels. I manually calculated on my first fillup after install and saw a drop from ~23 mpg to ~21.5. That was about 3 weeks ago. On my last fillup avg about 22.5 mpg. I doubt the ECU "adapted" to the wheel size. Maybe my driving habits have tamed a bit. Either way I think you are going to lose a little mpg as the mass the vehicle is moving has increased.

Appreciate
0

06262012, 01:36 PM  #18 
Major General
65
Rep 6,092
Posts 
in addition to the rolling calculation noted above already, heavier wheel weight and possible increase in traction from wider tires also affect gas mileage.
__________________

Appreciate
0

06262012, 01:59 PM  #19 
Private
0
Rep 89
Posts 
Did you say 5lbs per corner? If so, that's 20lbs of UNSPRUNG weight. That's pretty huge. BMW wheels are heavy. Ridiculously so. Coming from a world where most 18" high end rims were maybe 17lbs at the most(my 16" rims on my old car were under 16lbs), swallowing the weigh of these rims has been bitter medicine.
That said, to me, I can't deal with a weigh much over 20lbs on a 19" rim. Otherwise, I just see too much of a performance hit there. The comments above about rolling diameter are correct. Also, going to a wider and potentially stickier tire increases your rolling resistance too, which improves traction but at the cost of mileage. It's small, but all this stuff adds up. You add 20lbs of unsprung weight, that makes a difference too. It's more weight for your car to push forward(this is unsprung weight, not at all the same as what's riding on your suspension) and greatly affects handling. All this added together could easily account for your mileage drop. Both perceived and not real(the rolling diameter) and the real(increased weight and rolling resistance). 
Appreciate
0

06262012, 02:02 PM  #20 
BimmerPost Supporting Vendor
1078
Rep 24,595
Posts 
Generally, you want to keep your overall diameter within 3% of your OEM wheels. Even though your wheels are larger, the tires will compensate the difference in diameter. Just as long as you didn't go with a taller or shorter tire or something abnormally wide, you shouldn't see a HUGE difference in your MPG. The difference is mainly because your 19 inch wheels and tires are heavier than your stock 17's. Though it's only a few pounds, it's rotational weight.
www.1010tires.com/tiresizecalculator.asp < good tire calculator. Will show you overall diameter, circumference etc.
__________________
Brandon @ VMRWheels  714.442.7916 EXT. 108  Brandon@velocitymotoring.com  www.velocitymotoring.com  facebook  flickr  Instagram 
Appreciate
0

06262012, 02:04 PM  #21 
Second Lieutenant
7
Rep 239
Posts 
there are other posts that talk about when adding larger wheels that are heavier (more metal) and if you check tires, they are also heavier when going to 19" even though it looks like less rubber than 17"
that extra weight say 67 pounds extra on each wheel is 2428 per set. but because its a rolling weight, it is like having over carrying over a 100 pounds extra in your car. i noticed a bit of drop in mpg in mine, but i really noticed the power difference. (no 328 jokes pleaselol) i ride road bicycles and the biggest difference you can make it so go to lighter wheels. a wheel that is 1/2 pound lighter will make it feel like you got a new pair of legs! more so then getting a 2 pound lighter bike.
__________________
2011 328i RWD Sports 6MT, BMW P/E, aFe Magnum stage 2, AA tune, P3cars gauge, LUX

Appreciate
0

06272012, 01:09 AM  #22 
Captain
20
Rep 707
Posts 
To summarize many of the posts above, the difference in mileage could be caused by two things:
1. inaccurate odometer caused by new wheels/tires 2. heavier wheel/tire combination The OP stated he had style 161 wheels. The style 161 tires/wheels on my 328i e90 with ZSP are staggered with 225/45/17 tires up front and 255/40/17 tires in the rear. The following wheel/tire combinations have approximately the same diameter, circumference and revs per mile: 225/45/17 255/40/17 225/40/18 255/35/18 225/35/19 255/30/19 So, if you have 225/35/19's up front and 255/30/19's in the rear, the odometer should be very close to accurate. If not, your tires are probably wider which means the diameter and circumference would go up and revs/mile would go down. In other words, you are going farther than your odometer indicates because of the larger tire/wheel combo, which would explain the APPARENT drop in gas mileage. If you have 225/35/19's up front and 255/30/19's in the rear, then, as others have said, the drop in mileage (and performance) could be explained by heavier unsprung weight of the larger tire/wheel combo. Road & Track or Car & Driver did an article on this a few years ago. 
Appreciate
0

Bookmarks 
Thread Tools  Search this Thread 

