View Single Post
      08-14-2013, 05:03 PM   #66
Brigadier General
peterg1965's Avatar
United Kingdom

Drives: F30 335d M Sport, F15 X5 40d
Join Date: May 2007
Location: The place of dark satanic mills, UK

iTrader: (0)

Originally Posted by Gibbo View Post
Peter, my dad has an X5 40d SE Dynamic pack facelift which will be 3 yrs old end of year. He drives normally and 30 mpg is what it does, its a fair tank of a car and cannot say I like it much but admire what it can do. I am guessing he will buy the new one end of year or start of next when M sport or Dynamic 40d equivalent comes out.

If you are not using the 640d well it's dead money so that has to go and if it has to be a BMW then X5 or a 5 series touring seem your only option. If you can get shot completely a Skoda Superb Estate could be an equally good and cheaper option and new / next to new in comparison.

I guess the 6er never really floated your boat due to work commitments and time. My assumption with no disrespect is it's a bit of a dull old barge and the price per month for an expensive car was a big draw rather than stopping and thinking am I going to really enjoy driving this car.

Hope all goes well on the car search and looks like you are trying to get the best fit for current circumstances which is clearly the right way to go.
Great perception Peter, spot on. 5 Touring is just too small in the boot, sloping hatch kills the space. Skoda superb estate great car, but suspect would not fill Mrs 4x4 desires!

The 640d s a little soulless really, incredible car for the money and it has presence, but I will not miss it. It only has 8000 miles on the clock, so I shudder to thing of the per mile cost - let's not go there.

To be fair, now working in London, I personally have no need for a car (i am officially now a bus wanker), so it's all about fulfilling the Mrs vehicular needs and ensuring she is happy. She would be very very content with a 4x4 (an X5 would fit the bill for her) complemented by (yet another) automatic Mini.