|
|
|
|
|
|
BMW Garage | BMW Meets | Register | Today's Posts | Search |
|
BMW 3-Series (E90 E92) Forum
>
NOT impressed with IMPRESSIVE auto
|
|
01-29-2012, 01:24 AM | #1 |
Enlisted Member
2
Rep 41
Posts |
NOT impressed with IMPRESSIVE auto
This is an extremely condensed version, I have no enough hours in this day to fully get into every minute detail and instance but this will give readers plenty of insight.
I am sure most, if not everybody on this forum is familiar with IMPRESSIVE or, as I call them, NON-IMPRESSIVE auto. I know many people on this board have used them and posted positive responses, I also know there’s as many if not more on here whom have had a horrible experience. My m3 had broken down in the end of August, heard what sounded like marbles in a can rattling. I had it taken to my shop where we found metal in the oil pan and knew something had catastrophically failed. I searched around on the forums and found that IMPRESSIVE had done many engine swaps including a 330xi s54 (which actually excited me and made me think I can give them a shot), called up and spoke with John. At the time, John was extremely helpful, I told him the symptoms and in a instance he knew that I had spun a rod bearing, to which he stated the replacement would be, “no problem, I’ve done so many of these engines bro”. Car was flat bedded the next day over to his shop (the tow guy is VERY good, I would use him again). A few days later they had the diagnosing; it was in fact the rod bearing. John had said that the crank needed to be machined and etc., so we went ahead and placed an order for all OEM parts new. (Connecting rods, crankshaft, gaskets, cylinder, and head bolt, etc.) Crank was taken to 2 different shops, the first didn’t want to touch it or some excuse like that and the second found that it was actually cracked, so it needed to be replaced. There was a wait on the crank shaft which is understandable as no dealers had them in stock in the US and the part had to be ordered and delivered from Germany. This was in September, John asked me for cash up front for parts which I gave to him and didn’t hear from him for about 3 weeks, they never called to update me on the status of anything throughout this entire process its always me trying to track John down. The car was finished in November, 21st to be exact and I paid the rest of the bill and picked it up. My clutch did not feel right but John insisted it was the guibo which he changed as he said mine was cracked. It felt as if my pedal didn’t fully depress ( I have an upgraded clutch, far from OEM), I knew I had to do the proper break-in with this motor and adhered to the guidelines to the teeth (1k no revs about 4k, varying throttle and RPM, this in itself was a chore). Around 600 miles on the highway, I hear a pop and immediately started to smell burning oil. Not only did I smell it but I could see it pillowing out of my hood when I came to a light, I pulled into a parking lot and opened the hood. My engine was smoking for a solid half hour as I could see oil had spewed all over the engine compartment and was baking on the side of my block (thank god it was 32 degrees out that night). As I waited for Sha (john’s tow guy, who as I mentioned is 100% professional) I prayed nothing would explode. I spoke to john on the phone and he did not seem at all worried or bothered by this issue, saying it was most likely just a line and it’s no big deal. Fast forward two business days, I call him (as usual) and he says that the timing chain broke and it snapped my valve cover but my vanos looked fine. They replaced the said parts and he said they reassembled it and there was some code on. Ended up the vanos was shot (how I have no idea) and it needed to be replaced. Another line item on to the bill but it was going to get done and be perfect. I again waited until the job was allegedly completed and picked up the car. When I got there to pick up my car I discovered that (2) of my PERFECT OEM powder coated ZCP wheels had been rashed up. John immediately said it was most likely my mechanics that had the car prior to him but this just isn’t the case as my shop never ruins anything of mine and has built several of my cars without issues. (in retro spec I should have just had them do it but I didn’t). I told him it would cost $125 per wheel which is what I paid for them and he said I was over paying and his guy would do it, again “no problem”. So he took my two wheels to be fixed, I also discovered that the shop has reversed my car into something and cut into my custom molded rear dumper with CSL diffusor (see pic below) of course John was not there when I picked up the car and I was under time constraints so I took the car home, damaged. John had refunded me $125 for (1) wheel in which they put TOUCH UP paint on (which does not match at all and looks like garbage) and I had on the car in the interim a beat OEM 19 inch wheel with a totally beyond bald and bubbled tire. I brought the car home, changed my wheels to OEM 18s with blizzacks and put the garbage wheel in my trunk to be brought back to IMPRESSIVE because he needed to return my wheel, paint my bumper AND fix the CONTINUING OIL LEAK from my car. I brought the car back to IMPRESSIVE and waited until it was finished. Once again, I took a cab from my office in midtown back to IMPRESSIVE and picked up my car, it was raining out so I could not fully assess the quality of the repaint that was a necessity (due to them backing up my car into something) but it looked OK. I also grabbed my, allegedly, fixed wheel and tossed it in the trunk. I again drove the car home thinking everything was now good, and parked her in my garage. I live in NYC and keep the car out on LI so that weekend (3 days later) I went home and looked under the car, and again to my surprise, OIL LEAK. Called IMPRESSIVE back up and dropped the car off again and was told they would use dye and figure it out, I said explicitly that it was leaking from the top and explained exactly where I believed it was coming from. Spoke to them a few days later and it was in fact something related to a Vanos hose (was lead to believe on the last FIX that john said he replaced the houses and they couldn’t find the leak, I asked him DID he drive the car? And he said no they let it run for a few hours) so this meant to me, not a mechanic, that the car needed to be under load to leak oil which was evident by the fact he couldn’t find a leak and it would leak every time I drove the car home. So again, a fix on top of a fix, this was clearly an installation error once again. Picked the car up last evening and my clutch just doesn’t feel right, and there was some oil on the ground at the shop. At this point I am fed up with the jerking and the turn around. I did not previously mention but will here that I was charged the 2% CC processing fee which is the business cost of accepting a CC to begin with. He simply passed that fee off to me which is actually illegal unless I was offered a cash substitute that was lower than said price (see the excerpt from VISA’s website below, “Merchants are not allowed by Visa, MasterCard, Discover and American Express to pass along their credit card processing fees to consumers. Merchant agreements with these companies prevent any surcharge or fee from being added to the purchase simply because the form of payment is a credit card. But (you knew there would be a "but"), merchants can offer a discount off the normal price of a good or service for paying with cash or check. Read more: http://www.creditcards.com/credit-ca...#ixzz1kfkCkWhf No substitute was offered and even my bank just confirmed that isn’t legal and brought that point up to him on the phone this morning, to which he said it is legal and they would not be refunding me anything. I will leave out the cash values for now as they are irrelevant in informing our community here about a shady merchant but values are significant. At this point I would highly recommend not using IMPRESSIVE for anything at all, there is no consistency there at all, the mechanic who built my engine has been fired and replaced and the new guy was essentially fixing and cleaning up the old guys mistakes, I had said that there should be no mistakes and if I wanted mistake I would have done this job myself on my free time in my garage and not paid, what I believed to be professionals, to do an unprofessional job. I will gladly elaborate on any of these points via PM as I do not want to bash other work that I saw occurring there that was sub-par at best. The representative from my credit card company got back on the line with me this morning after speaking with John and said that was essentially a wasted call and he is pointless to speak with. To be brutally honest the worst part about this has been John’s attitude throughout the process, he is extremely unprofessional and starts screaming on the phone. He routinely would interrupt me and not even allow me to get in a word until I had to tell him to shut up and let me speak, as I am the customer paying him and he should listen to what I am saying and not shove sentences down my throat the entire conversation. Routinely would say I’ll call you back or at the end of the day and he would never call, I would have to chase him and he would give me some BS excuse that he was busy or something. He would berate me on the phone saying whatever I want, and lie about things like my car was on the lift the entire time it was at the shop (hence that reverse mark which was made in midair apparently). Never have I dealt with somebody who is just so disrespectful to a customer ever. Now in my field of work if you say you will call somebody back you best call somebody back, blatant lies and episodes of disrespect are not part of legitimate business, but then again all the signs now point to it not being legitimate so I guess it’s all fine in IMPRESSIVE’s book. Food for thought before you hand over your cash fellas. 4 months, 5 plus trips back and forth and thousands of dollars later and issues are still not fully resolved. Everything is going to be sorted properly and I am looking forward to moving on from this horrible situation which has caused extreme agita and stress. (From what I hear from people hanging out @ IMPRESSIVE, this is the common case with many people, they say ‘Never Again’) Cheers fellow forum members. |
01-29-2012, 01:58 AM | #3 |
Colonel
208
Rep 2,558
Posts |
Sounds like a HORRIBLE experience... I've had bad experiences but nothing THIS bad... rediculous. Thanks so much for the thorough review... it's always good to share these experiences in detail so others know exactly what to expect.
If you are still having problems with the car, or just want to get everything re-checked (I probably would want to get it re-checked because I wouldn't trust anything Impresive Auto has to say at this point if i were you), I'd highly recommend VAC Motorsports in Philly... it's a couple hours drive from you, but if you can manage to drop your car off there sometime, they have a very impressive shop with tons of hardware and very very experienced technicians who do a top notch job... it's not a normal body/performance shop... they do a lot of very technical work, custom race-car engine builds, transmission conversions (AT --> MT)... and they treat your car as if it were their own... call up Mike at VAC if you have a chance...
__________________
'07 Space Gray 335i coupe - R.I.P.
COBB ProTuned | AMS | CP-e | BMS | Quaife |
Appreciate
0
|
01-29-2012, 02:36 AM | #5 |
Captain
49
Rep 752
Posts |
^Direct effect of negative feedback due to poor customer service = lost business. Bravo. I hope you get this straightened out OP
__________________
2001 Chevy 2500HD Duramax
2003 VW Jetta TDI 2012 BMW F800GS 2024 BMW M2 BSM 6MT Carbon Package |
Appreciate
0
|
01-29-2012, 02:39 AM | #6 |
Captain
22
Rep 813
Posts |
o man im hopin my front bumper comes out well, just dropped it off a couple of days ago. now you got me worried man lol. hope everything works out though
|
Appreciate
0
|
01-29-2012, 07:59 AM | #8 |
Vengeance is mine, I shall repay
132
Rep 4,656
Posts |
ACM bro for engine stuff MAC for paint stuff....take the trip and spend the money once the right way....i had a similar experience with a different vendor here with my e93 and learned my lesson...they def wont be touching my new cts-v...ACM all day
hope you can get everything straightened out
__________________
Project: Vengeance[ACM's King of domestics, STOCK:501whp 489wtq | 2.9L whipple stock bottom end: 706whp 688wtq] Callies Compstar motor build:NEXT
|
Appreciate
0
|
01-29-2012, 08:36 AM | #9 |
Jerry's Fault...
175
Rep 9,258
Posts |
Some things will never change...
Last year there were PLENTY of reviews/threads like this. Even ones where people were going back for a re-spray more then once from the cheap paint job they did that was chipping in a matter of weeks (which they justify by saying "as long as you bring it back we'll paint it again free of charge"). Like anybody wants to keep going back and forth... I have a friend who had several parts painted there, including window trim that chipped (how window trim chips so easily when its not in direct contact with rocks like a front bumper or hood would be but ok) because honestly he thought MAC was too expensive for him. Well you get what you pay for. I like to call it "Pay now, or pay later. either way, your gonna pay..." Sad part is, this thread will prob be deleted just like all the other ones were last year. Guess if your a paying vendor on e90, that entitles you to get the moderators to delete any evidence of horrible work your shop may do... sorry to hear OP. Lesson learned... www.MartinoAutoConcepts.com
__________________
Boopie*Motorwerks Martino*Auto*Concepts |
Appreciate
0
|
01-29-2012, 08:56 AM | #10 |
Major General
369
Rep 8,693
Posts
Drives: 06 330i
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: The Promise Land
|
what a shame if this thread gets deleted....
can you dispute the charges OP? |
Appreciate
0
|
01-29-2012, 09:06 AM | #12 |
Sameet
739
Rep 2,541
Posts
Drives: AY/B M4 '15
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Long Island, New York
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
01-29-2012, 10:09 AM | #14 |
The Blue Beast
142
Rep 5,665
Posts |
ouch... hope everything gets sorted out. Definitely bring that to ACM to get it up and running again.
__________________
Cobb AP Stage 2+ | BMS DCI | UR Catless DP | UR Chargepipe | Tial BV 50mm | BSH OCC | ETS FMIC | Eisenmann Race Exhaust | KWv1 Coilovers | Volk TE37 TC Kline Ed. |
Appreciate
0
|
01-29-2012, 10:17 AM | #15 | |
441
Rep 18,331
Posts |
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
01-29-2012, 11:20 AM | #16 |
Major
245
Rep 1,236
Posts |
^ smh at quoting the whole OP. I went to IMPRESSIVE to have my bumpers switched and they were bending and pulling my bumper off and being anything but delicate towards it. I thought it was going to snap. The guys had no idea what they were doing. While I was in there I saw the OP's engine scattered around the shop. Anything but professional if you ask me.
__________________
2007 e90 335i: Single Turbo 700whp (Sold)
2009 e82 135i: Jb4 Only (Sold) 2010 e92 M3: Macht Schnell Intake, AA Pulley, IPE F1 Full Exhaust, 100% e85, RK Tunes Custom Tune (400whp) |
Appreciate
0
|
01-29-2012, 11:25 AM | #18 |
Major
245
Rep 1,236
Posts |
I'm pretty sure Wilazn had his bumper painted there and it didn't match at all
__________________
2007 e90 335i: Single Turbo 700whp (Sold)
2009 e82 135i: Jb4 Only (Sold) 2010 e92 M3: Macht Schnell Intake, AA Pulley, IPE F1 Full Exhaust, 100% e85, RK Tunes Custom Tune (400whp) |
Appreciate
0
|
01-29-2012, 11:32 AM | #19 |
Major
67
Rep 1,284
Posts
Drives: BMW 335i DINAN 3
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: NJ
|
I'm glad i never brought my car there, I was thinking of getting my car resprayed last year and saw a thread about how bad the quality of paint job. As far as i know yea Wilazn did get his hood painted by them. Either way i wouldn't take a BMW to a shop like that, that has so many negative reviews. Good Luck OP!
__________________
|
Appreciate
0
|
01-29-2012, 12:02 PM | #20 |
Photographer
141
Rep 1,634
Posts |
Damn, thats pretty sad..
I believe its tough to find places give cars that needed extreme attention, and not work at 10 cars at the same time, and I speak on the repair work.. I think BMW are still complex for many, and every little thing missed, is more damage on its way out.. But according to what you describe, I wouldnt even set foot, or pay a dime unless everything was straight, cause that repair over repair, I believe is bullshit.. I wish you good luck, and if you need tows out of brooklyn holla...
__________________
ENRON = We Take Your Money and Run!!!
"Never bring a Camera to a Gun Fight, You never know who you might Point n Shoot at!!!" "Victims, arent we all?" http://photowithart.com/ |
Appreciate
0
|
01-29-2012, 12:58 PM | #21 |
Brigadier General
149
Rep 3,552
Posts |
Dam i was about to bring my bumper to them....
Passing off credit card fee's is just terrible move, i too run a business and customer service is REALLY IMPORTANT. you cannot disrespect a customer no matter what. resolve the issue or do the job right! |
Appreciate
0
|
Bookmarks |
|
|